About Us
ISU / McCormick-Metsker Agency is an Independent Insurance Agency, which means we represent many different companies so we can find the one that is right for you. We can shop your insurance for you instead of you having to call around.
Our goal is to provide you with the insurance you want at the lowest possible price, while providing you with the highest level of customer service. We can furnish you with an assessment of your insurance needs and a choice of which package fits you best.
It helps to find an agency that you know and can trust. Our staff has the knowledge and experience of our insurance products to provide maximum benefit and protection to our clients. Let one of our licensed professional insurance agents help you with any of your personal or business insurance needs serving Crawfordsville, Indiana.
Tim McCormick -
Sales Agent, owner/operator. - (Direct: Extension 15)
Tim is a Graduate of Southmont High School and attended Indiana University in Bloomington, IN in the schools of business and music. In 1976 Tim joined the staff of McCormick-Metsker Agency, Inc., an agency owned and operated by his family since 1956 in Crawfordsville, IN. Tim and his brother Mike...
Mike Utterback -
Sales Agent, owner/operator. - (Direct: Extension 12)
Mike has lived and worked in Montgomery County for most of his life. He has been in the insurance industry for more than 21 years. Mike has extensive training in many areas of insurance and risk management including home, auto, farm, estate planning, buy/sell agreements, health, nursing home and ...
Bill Whalen -
Sales Agent - (Direct: Extension 11)
Personal, Business and Commercial lines.
Stephan Utterback -
Sales Agent - (Direct: Extension 20)
Personal, Business and Commercial lines.
Mike McCormick -
Sales Agent, owner/operator. - (Direct: Extension 14)
Mike is a lifelong resident of Montgomery County and has an extensive background in insurance and risk management. Mike is active in many industry associations as an educator, advocate and speaker on a local and state level. His experience and knowledge in the industry assure that each client wil...
